India’s Employment Guarantee: Wages, Entitlements and Service Delivery

RESEARCH QUESTION

To what extent have agricultural wages responded to the introduction of India's National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS)? Can delivery of NREGS benefits be improved by informing the target population of their entitlements under the scheme? What, if any, impact has NREGS had on income growth and poverty amongst the poor?

PROJECT

India's National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) legally guarantees 100 days of paid work per year for any rural household that is willing to undertake unskilled or semi-skilled wage work. The high-profile scheme was introduced in 2005 and extended to all of India in 2008. Its twin aims are to provide a safety net for the poor in the form of locally available wage work, and to promote economic growth by channelling these labour resources towards the creation and restoration of local productive assets such as rainfall reservoirs, irrigation channels, wooded areas and roads. Low wage rates along with the manual nature of the work are intended to ensure that only the needy apply. However, as with many public schemes in developing countries NREGS faces serious implementation problems, and its real impact on growth and poverty is also being questioned.

One of the aims of the NREGS is to promote economic growth by creating and restoring rainfall capture systems, irrigation channels and other ‘productive assets' used by the poor. Local economic growth is difficult to measure, so instead we propose to look at local agricultural wages. The bulk of the rural labour force is employed in agriculture, and given that the poorest typically own little land of their own and rely on wage income, agricultural wages are a good proxy for the income and welfare of the poorest. Agricultural wages series therefore offer a way to measure and track ‘pro-poor growth'.

There are two ways in which the NREGS may be thought to have an influence on agricultural wages. One is by investing in capital which makes workers more productive and thereby increasing the return on labour input. The other is by changing local labour market conditions. If the scheme increases the demand for local labour under sufficiently attractive conditions, the market-clearing wage rate would be expected to increase. One might expect the effect to be particularly pronounced in the agricultural slack season, when labour demand is low. In addition, it is possible that agricultural labour will be more productive because the workers are generally better off and thus healthier.

Several long-running national data series collect agricultural wages at the local level. We will pair these data with information about the NREGS rollout schedule and intensity of operation in the same regions in order to assess the impact of the scheme on wages.

We will also investigate whether the delivery of NREGS services can be improved by informing the target population of their entitlements. We propose to undertake a campaign to inform intended beneficiaries of their entitlements under the NREGS. The campaign will be randomly allocated, and we will compare various measures of scheme efficiency before and after the campaign, across treatment and control locations. This will allow us to discuss the causal effect of providing entitlement information on the quality of service delivery in a large-scale and high-profile public programme.

RESEARCHERS

Erlend Berg

Ramachandra Manjula

Durgam Rajasekhar

OUTPUT

Public Works, Local Democratic Institutions and Climate Smart Agriculture: Lessons from India

Durgam Rajasekhar, Erlend Berg, Ramachandra Manjula

Presented by D Rajasekhar at CSAE Conference, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK. March 23-25, 2014

Talking to Ghosts: Quantifying Forged Employment Records in MGNREG

Durgam Rajasekhar, Erlend Berg, Ramachandra Manjula

D Rajasekhar October 9, 2013 CMDR, Dharwad, Karnataka, India

Can Rural Public Works Affect Agricultural Wages? Evidence from India

Erlend Berg, Sambit Bhattacharyya, Durgam Rajasekhar and Ramachandra Manjula

Presented by Sambit Bhattacharya at '7th IZA/World Bank Conference: Employment and Development', New Dehli, India. Nov 4 - 6, 2012

NREGS, Gram Panchayats and Inclusive Climate-Smart Agriculture: Evidence from South India

Durgam Rajasekhar, Erlend Berg and Ramachandra Manjula

Presented at the PRi/CCAFS Workshop on Institutions for Inclusive Climate-Smart Agriculture September 10th-13th, 2012. Nairobi, Kenya

Can rural public works affect agricultural wages? Evidence from India

Erlend Berg, Sambit Bhattacharyya, Rajasekhar Durgam and Manjula Ramachandra

CSAE Working Paper WPS/2012-05, May 2012

Service Delivery and Corruption in the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS)

Erlend Berg, R Manjula, D Rajasekhar

Presented at iiG workshop, Oxford, 19 Mar 2011